1132 Views

what are the problem encounter in the use of literary source for writing ancient history ?illustrate with examples(300 words)


Shahid kuchay 14th Jul, 2020
Answer (1)
Prajakta Parade 19th Jul, 2020

There are quite a few problems encountered in the use of “literary sources” for writing Ancient Indian History. The first and foremost one is the wrong selection of the “research venue” that leads the research work in a wrong direction.

Take the case of “academy” in the form of a research venue. Only a small fraction of academy happens to serve as the venue of research, when the rest of it has come to wear a surreptitious anti-research design. The effect of the latter outweighs that of the former. So, the net result is “anti-research”. You have to take note of it and save your research spirit from this ultimate peril. Let me explain.

When we are talking about “historical research”, you would tend to look forward to academy’s “history cell” for genuine ambience. You could be making a mistake then. Because, this cell could already have been an “anti-research anti-history trap” under existing conditions. How?

A “civilized nation” would certainly have been aware of the fact that “history” and “historical information in the form of original historical texts” is a “civil property”. It also would have been aware of the fact that the “doctrine of civil epistemic sovereignty over historical information and historical research” is never to be surpassed by “salaried history-cell professionals” who would have been appointed for collection and transmission of historical information.

Naturally, this invaluable and indispensable civil property would have to be governed by nation’s highest civil body (“national body”) which would be wielding the “epistemic authority” for collection and preservation of historical information, for historical research and for appointment of salaried professionals. The latter would work as servants of the history cell and would have to be supervised continually, lest they should commit the anti-national blunder of trying to usurp civil epistemic sovereignty and of trying to give their professional work an aura of originality.

Related Questions

Question : Comprehension:
Read the given passage and answer the questions that follow.
Plato is the earliest important educational thinker, and education is an essential element in 'The Republic' (his most important work on philosophy and political theory, written around 360 B.C.). In it, he advocates some rather extreme methods: removing children from their mothers' care and raising them as wards of the state, and differentiating children suitable to the various castes, the highest receiving the most education, so that they could act as guardians of the city and care for the less able. He believed that education should be holistic, including facts, skills, physical discipline, music, and art. Plato believed that talent and intelligence are not distributed genetically and thus can be found in children born to all classes, although his proposed system of selective public education for an educated minority of the population does not really follow a democratic model.

Aristotle considered human nature, habit, and reason to be equally important forces to be cultivated in education, the ultimate aim of which should be to produce good and virtuous citizens. He proposed that teachers lead their students systematically, and that repetition be used as a key tool to develop good habits, unlike Socrates' emphasis on questioning his listeners to bring out their own ideas. He emphasized the balancing of the theoretical and practical aspects of subjects taught, among which he explicitly mentions reading, writing, mathematics, music, physical education, literature, history, and a wide range of sciences, as well as play, which he also considered important.

Question:
What tool does Aristotle advocate to teachers to develop good habits in students?

Option 1: Writing

Option 2: Reading

Option 3: Questioning

Option 4: Repetition

19 Views

Question : Comprehension:
Read the given passage and answer the questions that follow.
Plato is the earliest important educational thinker, and education is an essential element in 'The Republic' (his most important work on philosophy and political theory, written around 360 B.C.). In it, he advocates some rather extreme methods: removing children from their mothers' care and raising them as wards of the state, and differentiating children suitable to the various castes, the highest receiving the most education, so that they could act as guardians of the city and care for the less able. He believed that education should be holistic, including facts, skills, physical discipline, music, and art. Plato believed that talent and intelligence are not distributed genetically and thus can be found in children born to all classes, although his proposed system of selective public education for an educated minority of the population does not really follow a democratic model.

Aristotle considered human nature, habit, and reason to be equally important forces to be cultivated in education, the ultimate aim of which should be to produce good and virtuous citizens. He proposed that teachers lead their students systematically, and that repetition be used as a key tool to develop good habits, unlike Socrates' emphasis on questioning his listeners to bring out their own ideas. He emphasized the balancing of the theoretical and practical aspects of subjects taught, among which he explicitly mentions reading, writing, mathematics, music, physical education, literature, history, and a wide range of sciences, as well as play, which he also considered important.

Question:
Children who are imparted the highest education would be responsible for:

Option 1: developing talent and skills

Option 2: inculcating good habits

Option 3: guarding the city

Option 4: teaching the illiterate

30 Views
Amity University Admissions 2025
Apply
Amongst top 3% universities globally (QS Rankings) | Ranked as India’s #1 Not for profit pvt. University by India Today
UPES MA Admissions 2025
Apply
Ranked #46 Among Universities in India by NIRF | 1950+ Students Placed 91% Placement, 590+ Recruiters | Last Date to Apply: 14th August
Manav Rachna-MRIIRS B.A Admis...
Apply
NAAC A++ Grade | 41000+ Alumni network | Students from over 20 countries
Graphic Era (Deemed to be Uni...
Apply
NAAC A+ Grade | Among top 100 universities of India (NIRF 2024) | 40 crore+ scholarships distributed
Shoolini University Admission...
Apply
NAAC A+ Grade | Ranked No.1 Private University in India (QS World University Rankings 2025)
Amity Online MBA
Apply
Apply for an Online MBA from Amity Online.
View All Application Forms

Download the Careers360 App on your Android phone

Regular exam updates, QnA, Predictors, College Applications & E-books now on your Mobile

150M+ Students
30,000+ Colleges
500+ Exams
1500+ E-books